I’m sure plenty of gamers have spent hours scouring through Metacritic scores, all whilst trying to find out how well the latest over-hyped release has reviewed and whether it’s worth picking up on release day or waiting for a price cut. I know I’ve been guilty of it, though I’ve also enjoyed taking a look at older titles and seeing how well they performed with critics too.

It turns out that some games performed a lot better than I thought, whilst others have been criminally under-rated – it’s an unfair world, right? With that in mind, I thought it’d be a good idea to see how some games compared against each other and then quiz readers as to which one they think did better. Think you know your video game scores? Find out down below! Oh, and if a game has multiple scores across different platforms we’ll always go for the highest one, so no dodgy ports will ruin a game’s chances here.

Don’t forget to visit Metacritic to find out how well all of your favourite games have reviewed! 


Everyone loves a game that stars vampires, right? Well, both these two allowed you to actually be one, but which was better received by critics?